The Greatest Commandment
Home Moravian Church October 25, 2026
Craig Atwood
Matthew 22:34-46
When the Pharisees heard that he had silenced the Sadducees, they gathered together, and one of them, an expert in the law, asked him a question to test him. “Teacher, which commandment in the law is the greatest?” He said to him, “‘You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind.’ This is the greatest and first commandment. And a second is like it: ‘You shall love your neighbor as yourself.’ On these two commandments hang all the Law and the Prophets.”
I’m going to skip the rest of our assigned reading because I think it takes us away from the main point of this passage. We can talk about it another time.
Now while the Pharisees were gathered together, Jesus asked them this question: “What do you think of the Messiah? Whose son is he?” They said to him, “The son of David.” He said to them, “How is it then that David by the Spirit calls him Lord, saying, ‘The Lord said to my Lord, “Sit at my right hand, until I put your enemies under your feet”?”If David thus calls him Lord, how can he be his son?”
No one was able to give him an answer, nor from that day did anyone dare to ask him any more questions
INTRODUCTION
It’s been quite a week for me and for Home Church. The CROP walk, candle trimming, Candle Tea training, Bible studies, praying with color, bringing flowers to folks who can’t come to church, and bunch of other things I don’t even know about. Do you know what all these things have in common? Love of God and love of neighbor. It is a beautiful thing to experience, and I invite everyone to join in these activities.
FORSYTH JAIL AND PRISON
It was a busy week, but Wednesday was an unusually full and blessed day me this week. I don’t normally leave the house before sunrise. It usually takes me 30-40 minutes of stretching before my body wants to move. And I have to have a cup of fresh coffee while I do Wordle and Connections. Then I read the NY Times online. And have a second coffee while I read my eclectic news feed. Then I’m ready to get showered and dressed and drive into town.
But on Wednesday I headed down to the convention center in the gloaming for breakfast with about 400 people, including members of Home Church. We all came downtown to support the Forsyth Jail and Prison Ministry. We heard from a man who had been incarcerated for 16 years and is now free. Thanks to the work of the ministry, he is not just free in body; he is free in soul. He had been loved into being a different person than he was, and now he’s starting his own business and learning to be a good father and loving his children into being.
KIWANIS
My lunch on Wednesday was with the Twin City Kiwanis Club, which, as Gary Hauser can tell you, is the greatest Kiwanis Club in the world. We watched a documentary made by one of our members about a young woman who successfully completed a bicycle race across America. She was doing it to raise money and awareness for the fight against brain cancer. It was inspiring in many ways, but the most important thing I saw in the film is that she had been loved into being. She is a remarkable woman who was supported by her traveling crew and the great cloud of witnesses on line. She finished the race, but the real victory was when she kept going after near disaster on the second. She endured pain and fatigue not for glory but for love.
RABBI CHARLIE
My dinner on Wednesday was with nearly a hundred people from this congregation at our Wednesday Night Fellowship. Our special guest was Rabbi Charlie Cytron-Walker and three members of his congregation. Rabbi Charlie is the rabbi for Temple Emmanuel, and he has a Wikipedia page because when he was a rabbi in Texas he and several congregants were held hostage by a man who wanted to kill Jews. Charlie reacted with wisdom, courage, and compassion to keep the man calm for eleven hours until he and the other hostages were able to flee to safety. It is a thrilling story, but what is most remarkable is that Rabbi Charlie chose to continue to be a rabbi, to teach and care for his congregation, and share a meal and fellowship with Moravians and others. This kind of love melts hatred.
On Friday I rested because God wants us to rest. Julie and I played with our granddaughter because we are helping to love her into being a child of God who rejoices in the beauty of this world and embraces people in love rather than hiding from them in fear. And after worship today, this congregation will meet in love to embrace our mission to love and nurture our neighbors as we worship and love our God.
JESUS
With all that going on around me, I also thought deeply about our gospel lesson for today. For several weeks we have been hearing Jesus arguing with religious and political authorities who disagreed with him, who doubted him, who feared him, and who wanted to silence him. I think that Matthew brought all these stories together to help us understand why Jesus was arrested and killed. He disturbed the status quo by raising questions about the law and shining a light on injustice and corruption.
Our lesson for today is probably familiar to most of you. I know that when I was a boy in Sunday School I was real happy that Jesus gave such a short reply to a long question about God’s laws. It’s nice to have something short that you can memorize and recite whenever a teacher asks you a question. Love God and love your neighbor! That’s the right answer to every question about theology and ethics.
But Jesus’ teaching is not a motto or a motivational mantra. This little teaching is profound and can be life changing. It is something to meditate upon every day and to live into every day. It’s not an answer; it is a question that calls us into a new understanding of our human existence.
MATTHEW’S VERSION
It is interesting that this same story appears almost word for word in the gospels of Mark and Luke, but those gospels have this story much earlier in Jesus’ ministry. In Mark and Luke, the lawyer who asked Jesus the question about the greatest commandment was deeply respectful of Jesus and acknowledged Jesus’ wisdom. In Matthew, the Pharisees conspire and ask him the question of the greatest commandment as a gotcha question. They wanted him to stumble so they could attack him. I think this is unfortunate because it diminishes the power and impact of Jesus’ message, but we lets unpack it a bit and let the light shine.
When the Pharisee addressed Jesus he usds the Greek word for teacher, didaskalos. That was the word that Greek-speaking Jews used for their rabbis. This may be seen as a sign of respect being shown to Jesus, but it may have used sarcastically to mock him. It’s hard to tell. But the question he asks is a good one. Which commandment is the most important?
Ove the years, the Rabbis agreed that there are 613 commandments given by God to the chosen people, including things they should do and things they should avoid. Some rabbis said that all 613 are all equally important. Others said that the Ten Commandments were the most important. Around the time of Jesus, Rabbi Hillel said the whole law while standing on one foot: Don’t do to others what you would hate them to do to you. Everything else is commentary, he said.
Earlier we heard Page read Leviticus 19, which Jesus quoted in his reply to the Pharisee’s question. Like a good rabbi, Jesus went to the Torah and presented his point of view. “Love the Lord your God with all your heart, soul, and mind. And love your neighbor as yourself.” Jesus didn’t make this up. Jesus learned this in synagogue as a child. This was the summary of the Bible. Jesus’ whole life was an illustration of the meaning of these two verses. All the other commandments are ways of interpreting what it means to love God and your neighbor.
LOVE
But what is love? You may know about the different Greek words for love: eros, philios, and agape. Agape is used in this verse. Agape is not emotional love or desire. It is not the love of pop music, Valentine’s Day cards, or love of chocolate. It is not even the love we have in friendship or companionship. Agape is a complete and selfless form of love. To love God with one’s heart, soul, and mind is to seek union with God, to love what God loves, to love as God loves.
This is not just the love of mystics or martyrs; it is the love of everyone who seeks to do right because they love God. They aren’t trying to avoid punishment. They love God and want to please him. Worship, spirituality, reading the Daily Text, Bible study and all that we do in church are only part of the story. Love for God flows out into the world.
And that’s why Jesus added the second commandment. It is not less important. In fact, it is a necessary component of love of God. As many prophets have said through the centuries, you cannot love God while hating your neighbor. You cannot love God while exploiting others for your profit. You cannot love God while demeaning, dehumanizing, and denigrating any human being. You cannot love God while destroying God’s creation and pouring carbon into the atmosphere without concern for the future. Love means you care for God’s world and you care for God’s people.
John Amos Comenius summarized Jesus’ teachings in a beautiful way. All humans are made in the image of God. Despite sin and suffering, all humans still bear the image of God. Therefore, when you look at your neighbor you see God’s image. And God expects us to treat our neighbors with the reference we would show God.
I read recently that a study showed that White Protestants are more likely to claim that God’s truth or God’s law is more important having Empathy. Fewer than half of White Protestants think empathy should be the foundation for our actions. That was in great contrast to all the other religious groups. Some Protestants deny the importance this even though Jesus himself taught us that the greatest commandment is to love our neighbor. Empathy is the Christ’s law.
EXERCISE
I’m going to something a little different this morning by asking you to join me in a short exercise. First I want us to do something that Fred Rogers or Mr. Rogers used to do. Think about the people who loved you into being who you are. Whose love shaped you? Think about them for a moment, try to remember what they look like, and then silently offer a prayer of gratitude to God for them. PAUSE
Now, I want everyone to turn to someone sitting near you. You can do this in pairs or triads, but look around and make sure no one here is alone. Take a deep breath, look at them, and speak out loud the words “I love you.” And listen to them tell you that you are loved.. PAUSE
Now there’s a third aspect of Jesus’ teaching that we often forget. You are to love your neighbor as yourself. We cannot truly love God or others if we do not love ourselves. Much of the pain and misery in the world is caused by people who hate themselves. Sit quietly. Close your eyes. Take a deep breath. And say to yourself, “I love you.” PAUSE
CONCLUSION
The whole law and the prophets; the whole gospel and divine revelation; the whole meaning of the universe is contained in this teaching from Leviticus to love God with our whole being and to love our neighbors as ourselves. May we learn to love this world and its people with empathy, compassion, and courage.
PAUSE
I chose the next hymn because I think it beautifully lists the many things that we should be grateful for. These are the ways God shows love for us and these are things that God loves. I believe that gratitude is often the starting point for love and care for creation.






